• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Top Hat Creamery: Hand-Dipped Ice Cream & Friendly Service in Lincoln, IL

Top Hat Creamery in Lincoln, Illinois, is a charming ice cream parlor known for its generous hand-dipped servings and diverse, rotating flavors like rhubarb and blueberry waffle cone. The warm, attentive staff make every visit memorable, often accommodating families with personalized service. Beyond fantastic ice cream, their malts and shakes deliver rich, creamy indulgence that excites the palate. This local gem blends small-town warmth with exceptional treats, inviting both residents and visitors to savor quality desserts while exploring Lincoln’s historic sights. Top Hat Creamery truly offers a joyful and delicious experience worth traveling for.

Top Hat Creamery at a glance

  • Address 513 Pulaski St #9, Lincoln, IL 62656, United States
  • Phone +1 217-605-0026
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop .
  • Popular for Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Top Hat Creamery: Reviews & Ratings

Stacy Crook
5

A big serving size. Friendly staff. One of very few places in Lincoln to get hand dipped ice cream. A variety of flavors. Last summer they had rhubarb. Not sure why they don't have it this summer. It was SO GOOD!!!

DeShea Swaar
5

My kids and I had an awesome experience yesterday. We were there early before opening and she opened the store just for us!!! She let my kids try tons of flavors and the amount of icream we got for $13 was a great deal. Really nice staff and a wonderful experience overall. Highly recommend.

Bryce Heth
5

This place was amazing -- a great little ice cream shop that while not too far off the beaten path had some great small town vibes! The customer service was immaculate and the malts / shakes were incredible! Pro tip: get a shake with any of the ice cream flavors they have on "tap" and really blow your taste buds!

Ava L
5

Delicious and super sweet people. I recommend going there because everyone is kind and caring.

Jeff Longfellow
5

Incredible ice cream and great customer service! We tried the Blueberry Wafflecone, Birthday Cake, and some sort of Triple Chocolate flavor. Loved them all! We live 35 miles away and would make the drive to Lincoln again just to eat ice cream at Top Hat! Plus you can check out the courthouse and all of the other cool shops while you eat your ice cream!

Ethan Graue
5

Love Top Hat! Tried some of the new ice cream they have in and it’s top notch! Lisa and Jon rock!

Jeanne Appel
5

Top Hat is incredible and a great new spot to go in Lincoln Illinois. The atmosphere is very upbeat and friendly and the staff are great. One of the very best hot fudge sundaes I’ve ever had. The quality of the ice cream is evident in the flavor and smooth creamy texture. Great place to take the family for a treat with indoor and outdoor seating!!

Megan
5

Top Hat’s icecream is amazing! I usually get their ice cream flight that comes with a few kinds you pick out. I have tried multiple flavors and absolutely love each one. Very friendly service. Highly recommend!

Location

  • Top Hat Creamery
    Top Hat Creamery
    513 Pulaski St #9, Lincoln, IL 62656, United States Hotline: +1 217-605-0026

Located in the heart of Lincoln, Illinois, Top Hat Creamery is a gem for anyone seeking authentic, hand-dipped ice cream with a small-town charm. This welcoming ice cream shop stands out with its generous portions and a diverse selection of flavors, from classic favorites to seasonal surprises like the beloved rhubarb, which customers still fondly remember. The staff's friendliness and personalized service create a warm atmosphere, making every visit memorable.

What truly elevates the experience at Top Hat Creamery is their dedication to quality and community. Whether arriving early or during peak hours, the staff goes above and beyond—welcoming families, offering numerous samples, and ensuring each guest finds their perfect scoop. The malts and shakes, crafted with the same rich ice cream, add an indulgent twist, coaxing your taste buds into a delightful adventure.

I was genuinely impressed by how the place balances a cozy, small-town vibe with impeccable customer care. The flavors I sampled, including the Birthday Cake and Triple Chocolate, were rich and creamy without being overwhelming—each bite showcasing a careful attention to texture and taste. It’s no surprise that visitors travel miles just to return.

Top Hat Creamery is more than an ice cream shop; it’s a sweet slice of community spirit and quality craftsmanship. For anyone exploring the historic sites nearby or simply craving a satisfying treat, this spot is a must-visit destination that promises both comfort and delight.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards